|Title||A note on knowledge discovery and machine learning in digital soil mapping|
|Author(s)||Wadoux, Alexandre M.J.C.; Samuel-Rosa, Alessandro; Poggio, Laura; Mulder, Vera Leatitia|
|Source||European Journal of Soil Science 71 (2020)2. - ISSN 1351-0754 - p. 133 - 136.|
Soil Geography and Landscape
ISRIC - World Soil Information
|Publication type||Refereed Article in a scientific journal|
|Keyword(s)||mapping - pedometrics - random forest - soil science - variable selection|
In digital soil mapping, machine learning (ML) techniques are being used to infer a relationship between a soil property and the covariates. The information derived from this process is often translated into pedological knowledge. This mechanism is referred to as knowledge discovery. This study shows that knowledge discovery based on ML must be treated with caution. We show how pseudo-covariates can be used to accurately predict soil organic carbon in a hypothetical case study. We demonstrate that ML methods can find relevant patterns even when the covariates are meaningless and not related to soil-forming factors and processes. We argue that pattern recognition for prediction should not be equated with knowledge discovery. Knowledge discovery requires more than the recognition of patterns and successful prediction. It requires the pre-selection and preprocessing of pedologically relevant environmental covariates and the posterior interpretation and evaluation of the recognized patterns. We argue that important ML covariates could serve the purpose of providing elements to postulate hypotheses about soil processes that, once validated through experiments, could result in new pedological knowledge. Highlights: We discuss the rationale of knowledge discovery based on the most important machine learning covariates We use pseudo-covariates to predict topsoil organic carbon with random forest Soil organic carbon was accurately predicted in a hypothetical case study Pattern recognition by random forest should not be equated to knowledge discovery.